Wednesday, April 14, 2021
CHESAPEAKE CHURCH
  • Home
  • Local News
  • Church
  • Faith
  • Helping Needy
  • Education
  • Chesapeake
  • Christianity
  • Military News
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Local News
  • Church
  • Faith
  • Helping Needy
  • Education
  • Chesapeake
  • Christianity
  • Military News
No Result
View All Result
CHESAPEAKE CHRUCH
No Result
View All Result
Home Christianity

Can we synthesise Christianity moral theology with secular bioethics?

Amy Belcher by Amy Belcher
November 28, 2020
in Christianity
0
Can we synthesise Christianity moral theology with secular bioethics?
589
SHARES
3.3k
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter


A thought-provoking target article in the latest edition of The American Journal of Bioethics considers how Christian theological concepts might enrich secular bioethical discourse. Authors Michael McCarthy (Loyola University), Mary Homan (Medical College of Wisconsin) and Michael Rozier (Saint Louis University) argue that the Christian concepts of human dignity, sin, and the common good can bring analytical depth and clarity to discussions in a range of bioethical subfields, including debates clinical ethics, research ethics and public health ethics. In essence, they claim that “a Christian approach to bioethics can augment bioethical discourse by providing a thick theological description of the human person.” 

You might also like

Christians should use Easter to draw closer to God—Reverend Tetevi

Republicans Strongly Oppose Bills Forcing Americans To Fund Abortions : US : Christianity Daily

Don’t Let COVID Make You a Bad Parent – FREE WORKSHOP

The authors begin their article with a comment on the decline of dialogue between Christian moral theologians and secular bioethicists. Christian theologians had a significant impact on bioethics in its inception, though the influence of religious thought on bioethics has waned in recent years. The authors argue that this is due to both increasing secularism in society as well as a failure on the part of Christian ethicists to illustrate the relevance of Christian concepts for contemporary bioethics. This ‘communication breakdown’ is regrettable, and the authors express a desire to establish a new dialogue between Christian moral thought and secular bioethics. 

To demonstrate the importance of Christian moral concepts, the authors provide a series of ethical vignettes from different subspecialties of bioethics, and consider how Christian moral thought might enrich our thinking about these issues. In research ethics, the authors argue that issues of injustice arise regularly, including problems with minorities either being excluded from research or being exploited in research. Theology, they contend, can enrich our understanding of the effects of structural injustice in the context of research ethics:   

“theological bioethics argues for a critical reflection on what alternative choices need to be made to upset the power dynamic and disrupt the social sin embedded within the practice of biomedical research”. 

In public health ethics, the authors note that public health experts often become preoccupied with utilitarian health goals, while failing to make space for individual interests in their framework. Related to this, they fail to prosecute the case for civic virtue and compliance with public health campaigns or orders: 

“[Public health ethics] makes no claim as to why it is significant that human beings share lives together or why we create communities. This lack of a compelling reason for community leads to a variety of problems, including the challenges in the United States around vaccination”.

What is needed in public health ethics is a robust conception of the common good, whereby the good of individuals is conceptually linked to the good of society. 

The authors conclude their article by noting that Christian view of humanity can provide a richer lens than standard bioethical principles through which to view contemporary issues: 

“…a Christian anthropological vision of the human person centered on an understanding of human dignity, sin, and the common good provide a unique perspective to pursue the social ethics concerns raised by many secular bioethicists”. 

The article is certainly a stimulating read, and it is admirable in its attempt to synthesise Christian ethical thought with the concerns of contemporary bioethics. Its diplomatic style, however, leads to certain glaring oversights — be they intentional or unintentional — in the discussion. The devil is in the details, as Wake Forest University bioethicist Nicholas Colgrove writes in a commentary: 

“…Securing agreement on general claims (like “respect human beings”) is easy but securing agreement on the meaning of these claims is not. For instance, Christians who insist that all humans have dignity cannot accept that access to safe abortion is a matter of justice or means of protecting the vulnerable… Reflection on the actual Christian concept of “human dignity,” therefore, leaves secular bioethicists with two choices: Accept the Christian concept and revise dominant secular moral norms or deprive the Christian concept of its core content.”





Source link

Tags: bioethicsChristianitymoralsecularsynthesiseTheology
Previous Post

State education commissioner visits Franklin County | Local News

Next Post

Travis Collins: Biker Church

Amy Belcher

Amy Belcher

Related Posts

Christians should use Easter to draw closer to God—Reverend Tetevi
Christianity

Christians should use Easter to draw closer to God—Reverend Tetevi

by Amy Belcher
March 28, 2021
Republicans Strongly Oppose Bills Forcing Americans To Fund Abortions : US : Christianity Daily
Christianity

Republicans Strongly Oppose Bills Forcing Americans To Fund Abortions : US : Christianity Daily

by Amy Belcher
January 27, 2021
Don’t Let COVID Make You a Bad Parent – FREE WORKSHOP
Christianity

Don’t Let COVID Make You a Bad Parent – FREE WORKSHOP

by Amy Belcher
February 23, 2021
What has changed (and what hasn’t) for Christians in 2020
Christianity

What has changed (and what hasn’t) for Christians in 2020

by Amy Belcher
November 28, 2020
Weekly Meanderings, 28 November 2020 | Jesus Creed
Christianity

Weekly Meanderings, 28 November 2020 | Jesus Creed

by Amy Belcher
November 28, 2020
Next Post
Travis Collins: Biker Church

Travis Collins: Biker Church

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recommended

Motorcyclist dead in Laurens Co. crash on Fairview Church Rd.

Motorcyclist dead in Laurens Co. crash on Fairview Church Rd.

October 31, 2020
Hank Aaron, civil rights leaders get vaccinated in Georgia Shots Rice Louis Sullivan Ambassador message

Hank Aaron, civil rights leaders get vaccinated in Georgia Shots Rice Louis Sullivan Ambassador message

January 6, 2021

Categories

  • Chesapeake
  • Christianity
  • Chronic Pain
  • Church
  • Education
  • Faith
  • Helping Needy
  • Local News
  • Military News
  • Personal Finances
  • Uncategorized

Don't miss it

LARRY GENE McDOWELL | West Virginia
Church

LARRY GENE McDOWELL | West Virginia

April 13, 2021
NAACP opposes Chesapeake election-year proposal
Chesapeake

NAACP opposes Chesapeake election-year proposal

April 13, 2021
How to volunteer and donate in New Jersey during the coronavirus outbreak (04/11/21)
Helping Needy

How to volunteer and donate in New Jersey during the coronavirus outbreak (04/11/21)

April 12, 2021
Meet the Black Cowgirl Behind the Literacy Program That Combines Reading and Horseback Riding
Church

Meet the Black Cowgirl Behind the Literacy Program That Combines Reading and Horseback Riding

April 10, 2021
Chesapeake senior community acquired for $68M
Chesapeake

Chesapeake senior community acquired for $68M

April 10, 2021
Governor Ralph Northam Endorses Terry McAuliffe for Governor
Church

Governor Ralph Northam Endorses Terry McAuliffe for Governor

April 8, 2021

Recent News

LARRY GENE McDOWELL | West Virginia

LARRY GENE McDOWELL | West Virginia

April 13, 2021
NAACP opposes Chesapeake election-year proposal

NAACP opposes Chesapeake election-year proposal

April 13, 2021

Categories

  • Chesapeake
  • Christianity
  • Chronic Pain
  • Church
  • Education
  • Faith
  • Helping Needy
  • Local News
  • Military News
  • Personal Finances
  • Uncategorized

Follow Us

Contact Us

© 2020 ChesaPeakeChurchOnline

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Local News
  • Church
  • Faith
  • Helping Needy
  • Education
  • Chesapeake
  • Christianity
  • Military News

© 2020 ChesaPeakeChurchOnline