Friday, February 26, 2021
CHESAPEAKE CHURCH
  • Home
  • Local News
  • Church
  • Faith
  • Helping Needy
  • Education
  • Chesapeake
  • Christianity
  • Military News
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Local News
  • Church
  • Faith
  • Helping Needy
  • Education
  • Chesapeake
  • Christianity
  • Military News
No Result
View All Result
CHESAPEAKE CHRUCH
No Result
View All Result
Home Education

Education funding in Arizona isn’t as bad as everyone says it is

Amy Belcher by Amy Belcher
October 25, 2020
in Education
0
Education funding in Arizona isn’t as bad as everyone says it is
585
SHARES
3.3k
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter


The case for Proposition 208, which would give Arizona one of the highest state income tax rates in the country, is partly based on an incorrect history of education funding in Arizona.

The pitch by proponents is that the Arizona Legislature routinely cuts K-12 funding so voters have to take it into their own hands, however flawed Proposition 208 might be. The historical record, fully considered, doesn’t bear that out. 

The recession in the late 2000s, resulting from the busting of the residential real estate bubble, hit state revenues hard. They fell by about a third.

Lawmakers tried to minimize school cuts

The reaction of the Legislature, however, wasn’t to seize the opportunity to slash K-12 funding, as the caricature has it. Instead, it did nearly $7 billion of other things to stave off the need to do that.

It borrowed more than $2 billion against state buildings. It moved nearly $2 billion from other accounts into the general fund, which supplies most of the state funding for schools. And it referred to the voters a temporary, three-year increase in the state sales tax of one percentage point, which voters approved.

That raised $2.7 billion.

With the depth and length of the recession, even all that proved insufficient. A case could be made, and I made it at the time, that the temporary sales tax should have been extended. Instead, spending cuts were enacted.

School funding constituted roughly 40% of the state’s general fund. In a deficit, cuts to it can’t be avoided. So, the Legislature skipped a few inflation adjustments to basic state aid and reduced some other revenue streams. This was extremely stressful for schools.

Most cuts have been restored

Arizona Capitol

However, since the state’s economy has recovered, these cuts have been largely restored. Basic state aid has been increased vastly in excess of the skipped inflation payments. The other revenue streams have been largely replenished.

You will hear opponents proclaim that, despite all this, schools are still receiving $1 billion a year less in per-pupil funding, adjusted for inflation, than they were in 2008. This is an outdated calculation.

Based upon the current budget, the real deficit is $665 million. And even that is misleading.

In 2008, the state was building lots of new district schools. Since then, virtually all the enrollment growth has gone to charter schools.

The state doesn’t fund new charter schools. They have to fend for themselves. So, there’s a material flaw in using 2008 as a point of comparison. 

Proponents use it because it was the high water mark for inflation-adjusted, per-pupil funding. That’s understandable, but an exclusive focus on 2008 is distorting. Current inflation-adjusted, per-pupil funding exceeds that of 2004, for example.

Want a truth test? Look at the spending limit

A longer look is highly instructive. In 1980, Arizona voters adopted an aggregate limit on what schools can spend from state and local sources. The limit was what was being spent in 1980 on a per-pupil basis, adjusted for inflation, plus 10%. The Legislature could override the limit.

You might also like

How Chiropractors Treat Neck Pain

State education commissioner visits Franklin County | Local News

If turkey has worn thin by now, deer provides welcome alternative | Education

In 1986, the Legislature referred to voters an additional 10% boost to the expenditure base, which was approved. 

The Legislature passed an override to this increased limit in 2002. It also referred to the ballot an exemption to the limit for proceeds from an earmarked education sales tax voters previous approved. The exemption was passed.

Despite the exemption, overrides were required in 2007 and 2008. The restorations have been so extensive that the Legislature’s budget staff expects that another override will be needed next session.

This is hard, legal evidence of substantial increases in inflation-adjusted, per-pupil funding over time, including in recent years. Matt Beienburg of the Goldwater Institute calculates that inflation-adjusted, per-pupil funding in Arizona has increased 42% since 1980.

It’s worth noting that the Legislature was the moving party for all of these increases. It was the Legislature that overrode the expenditure limit and referred increases to its base to voters. It was the Legislature that referred the earmarked sales tax for education to voters, and the Legislature that recently voted to extend it directly. It was the Legislature that referred a temporary sales tax increase to the ballot to stave off deeper spending cuts.

What history really shows us

The real history is this: When there is dough, the Legislature has given priority to increased K-12 funding. In times of shortfall, the Legislature has taken extraordinary steps to minimize the impact to K-12.

Yes, income tax rates have been cut during this period. But to levels comparable to our neighboring states. They have kept the state economically competitive.

Is the state spending enough on K-12 education? I don’t think so and have proffered several ideas for consumption tax increases. Consumption taxes aren’t negatively correlated with economic growth the way income taxes are, particularly high marginal rates such as Proposition 208 would enact.

Regardless, the state’s economy shouldn’t be put at risk to punish lawmakers for sins they haven’t really committed.

Reach Robb at robert.robb@arizonarepublic.com.



Source link

Tags: Arizonabadeducationfundingisnt
Previous Post

Search for a Christian in America and find truth

Next Post

Local Church Puts Out the Call for Blood Drive to Help Huntington Hospital – Pasadena Weekendr

Amy Belcher

Amy Belcher

Related Posts

Chiropractic Neck Adjustment
Chesapeake

How Chiropractors Treat Neck Pain

by Amy Belcher
February 13, 2021
State education commissioner visits Franklin County | Local News
Education

State education commissioner visits Franklin County | Local News

by Amy Belcher
November 28, 2020
If turkey has worn thin by now, deer provides welcome alternative | Education
Education

If turkey has worn thin by now, deer provides welcome alternative | Education

by Amy Belcher
November 28, 2020
Things worthy of thanks — a good education | News
Education

Things worthy of thanks — a good education | News

by Amy Belcher
November 28, 2020
Green Local Board of Education approves strategic plan
Education

Green Local Board of Education approves strategic plan

by Amy Belcher
November 27, 2020
Next Post
Local Church Puts Out the Call for Blood Drive to Help Huntington Hospital – Pasadena Weekendr

Local Church Puts Out the Call for Blood Drive to Help Huntington Hospital – Pasadena Weekendr

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recommended

Students slam Assumption for sharing church document on gay marriage – News – MetroWest Daily News, Framingham, MA

Students slam Assumption for sharing church document on gay marriage – News – MetroWest Daily News, Framingham, MA

October 24, 2020
Oregon Faith Report

Oregon Faith Report

November 11, 2020

Categories

  • Chesapeake
  • Christianity
  • Chronic Pain
  • Church
  • Education
  • Faith
  • Helping Needy
  • Local News
  • Military News
  • Personal Finances
  • Uncategorized

Don't miss it

Bartus Trew fund provides grant for Tubman project | News
Church

Bartus Trew fund provides grant for Tubman project | News

February 24, 2021
Report: Climate Change a Major Threat to Recreational Fishing
Chesapeake

Report: Climate Change a Major Threat to Recreational Fishing

February 24, 2021
San Antonio mayor, philanthropist organizing winter storm recovery funds to help residents
Helping Needy

San Antonio mayor, philanthropist organizing winter storm recovery funds to help residents

February 23, 2021
A Five Star Review of Western Branch Chiropractic Clinic
Chesapeake

A Five Star Review of Western Branch Chiropractic Clinic

February 23, 2021
Here is another Impressive Review of Western Branch Chiropractic in Chesapeake
Chesapeake

Here is another Impressive Review of Western Branch Chiropractic in Chesapeake

February 23, 2021
Western Branch Chiropractic in Chesapeake gets another Five Star Review
Chesapeake

Western Branch Chiropractic in Chesapeake gets another Five Star Review

February 23, 2021

Recent News

Bartus Trew fund provides grant for Tubman project | News

Bartus Trew fund provides grant for Tubman project | News

February 24, 2021
Report: Climate Change a Major Threat to Recreational Fishing

Report: Climate Change a Major Threat to Recreational Fishing

February 24, 2021

Categories

  • Chesapeake
  • Christianity
  • Chronic Pain
  • Church
  • Education
  • Faith
  • Helping Needy
  • Local News
  • Military News
  • Personal Finances
  • Uncategorized

Follow Us

Contact Us

© 2020 ChesaPeakeChurchOnline

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Local News
  • Church
  • Faith
  • Helping Needy
  • Education
  • Chesapeake
  • Christianity
  • Military News

© 2020 ChesaPeakeChurchOnline